Good food, fair price, good service. Nothing over the top, but a solid meal. Been there many of times and the burgers and steaks are excellent and not obnoxiously priced. Definitely worth going if you're in the area and want a steak or burger. Staff is nice too.

Great service, comfort food and nicely made drinks! Casual, yet professional atmosphere. Consistency is very common

This was a great stop to make, as it was recommended by one of my family members. Parking isn't too bad for the most part, with plenty of spaces to be filled. We were seated upon entering and asked if we wanted to sit inside or out. Our waitress, Kate, did a wonderful job from start to finish and accommodated us when we needed it. The menu has quite a variety to choose from, which I always personally enjoy. The steaks are what they're famous for, hence the name, but what caught my eye was the Fried Chicken Wrap. I substituted tatter tots with that dish, but does come with regular fries without the substitution. All of that was very good and left satisfied. I can't wait to explore more on this menu, because I'm sure most items are very tasty and filling. All in all, I was thrilled all around.

Could be the best burger and fries I ever had!! Price was right!! Wednesdays bartender was extremely efficient and entertaining!! I will drive 1 hour to make if happen again!!

We have been going to the Amenia steakhouse on and off for quite a while now. We stopped going back in 2021 because the quality did not justify the price. Tough steaks, wilted lettuce, so we stopped going. We had recently given it another shot and grateful that we did. The prices are still up there but the quality of the food is also much better. Steaks, burgers and even the fish and salad has improved. Wife loves the surf and turf and I always enjoy the fish and chips and the seafood linguini. Apps are usually very good also. Kinda the only drawback is the French onion soup always comes out luke warm. Atmosphere is always nice as well as the service and food. I would honestly say I would once again recommend enjoying a good meal at the Amenia steakhouse.

The food was out of this world. Atmosphere was awesome. The employees very friendly and helpful. Looking forward to coming here again very soon. It was a nice ride to get to the location. Thank you and Happy New Year! Mr and Mrs Michael Seaborg

Food price/quality (value) rating 9. The atmosphere is pub style. We stopped in here just for a couple beers,and ended up getting an order of stuffed potato skins, also. A limited, but well chosen draught list is offered. The potato skins were prepared and presented beautifully. The menu prices were a very good value.

First time enjoying dinner here last night as it was my other half's request for his birthday. We ordered the garden salad and New England chowder for starts along with lobster tail as our appetizer and the blackened ribeye steak with mashed and veggies on side. The salad was super fresh and crisp like it was just dug up from the garden, I love that! The boy says the chowder was amazingly delicious and creamy. The steaks were not so much "blackened" as you'd think with Cajun or southern spices and herbs, but seared nicely and tender with an au jus that's just addicting and makes the steak melt in your mouth! You'll want to dip everything on your plate into the au jus (as we did with the creamy garlicky mashed potatoes if you can call them that...more like perfect textured buttery heaven in your mouth!) We did ask the owner on the way out where he gets his beef because we do think it's scrumptious. Alas, the secret remains with the steakhouse So the loss of the one star: The lobster tail was a bit over cooked so I was a little disappointed as the texture then changes and it's not enjoyable, rather more chewable. Also, they brought all our food out at once so we did feel almost rushed and weren't able to take our sweet time there as we had hoped. But, overall we will absolutely be back to give Amenia Steakhouse another go! Their atmosphere is vibrant with diversity of people- and relaxing as the nice raw cut wood booths keep you cozy with your company, the temperature was just right (which I really appreciate) and their steaks are impressive!